Skip to main content

Fresh Island Flavors

Experience the vibrant Key West dining scene all around us. Discover fresh island flavors in harmony with the tropical ambiance of our rooftop terrace. Lounge by our pool and enjoy light fare and refreshing concoctions from the bar.
Enjoy a casual al fresco setting at La Te Da, a Key West favorite. Celebrate in the elegance of Martin's. Enjoy trendy dining at Nine One Five, where small plates and seafood take center stage.Save room for a slice of Key Lime Pie - a Conch Republic tradition.
Milagro Restaurant
Contemporary Latin Cuisine

Milagro Restaurant

Savor contemporary and creative Latin cuisine at this restaurant at the Santa Maria Suites, our sister resort. Savor bold Latin foods and flavors in a relaxing atmosphere in the heart of Key West. Expert chefs use the freshest ingredients to create visual works of art that taste as good as they look.

Popular Key West Restaurants

A vacation to the Florida Keys wouldn't be the same without fresh local seafood and waterfront dining. Key West boasts an amazing mix of restaurants, cafes, and eateries with an emphasis on island flavors. You'll also find international dishes, vegetarian cuisines and local specialties including conch fritters and Key Lime pie. Check out the dining scene in Old Town Key West, with everything from food trucks to trendy restaurants with ocean views. Enjoy perfect weather year-round and chill with a margarita on an outdoor patio.
  • Southernmost Beach Café

    Southernmost Beach Café

    At the southern end of Duval Street, Southernmost Beach Café is located directly on South Beach. Enjoy a casual dining atmosphere and specialty cocktails at this open air restaurant offering one of the best views in town.
  • Caroline’s


    Located right on Duval Street, come over to this open-air restaurant to relish some of the best Conch fritters in town. Caroline's offers a cool, relaxed atmosphere, fresh local ingredients and a bar where the staff serves all your favorite concoctions.
Seafood Restaurants
  • Blue Heaven

    Blue Heaven

    A free-spirited outdoor restaurant, Blue Heaven is famous for their colorful tables and chairs, great food, and local chickens and roosters that may stop by to say hello to diners. Located in Bahama village, its eclectic menu includes items such as Caribbean shrimp deglazed with Red Stripe beer and jerk chicken.
  • A&B Lobster House

    A&B Lobster House

    For a special night out, plan a meal at this elegant 2nd-floor restaurant, located on the Bight Marina. With white tablecloths and ocean views, A&B Lobster House can be counted on for the freshest seafood combined with amazing harbor views.
  • Conch Republic Seafood Company

    Conch Republic Seafood Company

    Also located on the Bight Marina, Conch Republic Seafood Company (known as Conch Farm to the locals) is a favorite for fresh seafood, happy hour specials and fun, Key West ambiance.
  • Half Shell Raw Bar

    Half Shell Raw Bar

    The cover art for Kenny Chesney's When I See This Bar single, Half Shell Raw Bar is a favorite for fresh seafood and casual atmosphere at the Historic Seaport. It's also the only seafood restaurant in Key West that runs its own Fish Market.
  • Turtle Kraals

    Turtle Kraals

    Turtle races, oyster bar and fresh seafood ceviche are just a few of the specialties at this Historic Seaport bar. Head up to the upper deck and enjoy unbeatable views of the marina and a front row seat to the sunset.
Steak And Lobster Restaurants
  • Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House

    Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House

    Open since 1948, Duffy's arguably serves the finest steaks and seafood in Key West in a casual atmosphere at affordable prices. From prime rib to whole fresh Maine or Florida lobster, Duffy's decadent menu won't disappoint.
  • Bel Mare

    Bel Mare

    Discover the exotic Fine Italian Dining with fantastic views overlooking the historic Key West. Enjoy cooked-to-order steaks, homemade pasta dishes, creatively crafted cocktails, and an extensive wine list just a mile away on Simonton Street.
Italian Restaurants
  • Antonia’s


    Located on Duval Street, Antonia's is a Key West landmark serving handmade pasta created in-house daily. They specialize in finely crafted sauces, pristine local seafood and a carefully curated bar to ensure a delicious meal you won't soon forget.
  • Mangia Mangia

    Mangia Mangia

    Known for their fresh homemade pasta, Mangia Mangia's delicious menu offers spaghetti with green-lipped New Zealand mussels and a variety of other pasta dishes. Mangia Mangia is located in the heart of Old Town at the corner of Southard and Margaret streets and offers both indoor and outdoor patio seating.
  • Abbondanza


    The winner of The People's Choice for favorite Italian restaurant in Key West for many years, Abbondanza offers an extensive selection of pasta and other Italian favorites. Its Old Town Key West location, friendly atmosphere and great service make this a top choice for locals and visitors alike.
  • La Trattoria

    La Trattoria

    An enticing selection of fresh Italian dishes and quality wine served in an opulent atmosphere that transports you back to elegance in 1983. Sip the original Martini or taste the exotic seafood prepared with only the freshest ingredients. La Trattoria features authentic Italian cuisines with an array of choices in Martini at Duval Street.
Caribbean Restaurants
  • El Meson De Pepe

    El Meson De Pepe

    Located in Mallory Square, El Meson De Pepe has been crafting authentic Cuban food and drinks for over 30 years. Dine in or visit their patio bar after the sunset celebration for a fresh mojito and live music performance.
  • El Siboney

    El Siboney

    A bit of a hidden treasure, El Siboney is located in the small mid-town neighborhood on Catherine Street. The Cuban cuisine menu features a variety of authentic Cuban meals including pork, beef, seafood and chicken dishes.
Sushi Restaurants
  • Origami Sushi Bar

    Origami Sushi Bar

    For a Key West casual option, Origami Sushi Bar is located in Duval Square and offers a quaint garden patio looking out onto the square. This Japanese Bistro complete with fresh sushi bar is the perfect casual dining option.
Tacos And Burritos
  • Amigo’s


    A tortilla bar with casual bar counter seating, Amigo's is the perfect place to people-watch while sipping a cold Corona and enjoying a Baja fish burrito. They're also the Home of the Square Taco, a taco machine they invented to hold more fillings with less spilling!
  • Garbo’s Grill

    Garbo’s Grill

    At the Northern end of Duval, you'll find another Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives sensation: Garbo's Grill. The eclectic menu also features fresh local seafood, but it's known for its Umami burger featuring ½ pound of Angus beef, Applewood bacon and chipotle Gouda.
  • Banana Café

    Banana Café

    Back at our end of Duval, Banana Café is known for their rooftop terrace and authentic French flavors. Their breakfast, lunch and dinner menu offer a wide variety of options including delicious homemade crepes & quiches.
  • Frenchie’s Café

    Frenchie’s Café

    Located next to H2O Suites, Frenchie's Café is the favorite spot on the carousel. Popular breakfast/lunch spot that serves French classics and delicious breakfasts. Back at our end of Simonton Street, try out the authentic French flavors with a wide variety of options, including delicious homemade crepes & quiches.