Skip to main content
Reviews & Accolades

The Talk of Key West

In Old Key West is a new destination where modern luxury is reinvented. Step into beautifully designed suites and embrace the spirit of living well. Relax by the rooftop pool and embrace the laid-back vibe people rave about. The most award-winning hotels in Key West.

If we sound a bit biased, read our accolades and latest guest reviews.
  • 2026
    TripAdvisor Traveler's Choice Best Of The Best - Voted top 1% of Hotels in the Unites States for Luxury and Small & Boutique Categories.
  • 2025
    • Rated #8 in Best Key West Hotels - US News & World Reports 2025 Rankings
  • 2024
    • Travelers' Choice Awards By Tripadvisor
  • 2023
    • Winner Hotel by Haute Grandeur - Global Awards; 2023
    • Best Romantic Hotel by Haute Grandeur - Global Awards; 2023
    • Best Boutique Hotel by Haute Grandeur - Global Awards; 2023
    • Best Island Hotel by Haute Grandeur - Global Awards; 2023
    • Best Prime Location Hotel by Haute Grandeur - Global Awards; 2023
    • Best of the Best by TripAdvisor; 2023
  • 2022
    • Rated Best of the Best in the United States by TripAdvisor
    • Luxury Lifestyle Award 2022
    • Haute Grandeur "Best Boutique Honeymoon Hotel in North America" 2022
    • Haute Grandeur "Best Boutique Hotel in North America" 2022
    • Haute Grandeur "Best Island Hotel in North America" 2022
  • 2021
    • Rated Best of the Best in the United States by TripAdvisor
    • Rated #13 Most Romantic Hotel in the United States by TripAdvisor
    • Rated #6 Hotel in Key West by US News and World Reports
    • Best Boutique Honeymoon Hotel in North-America by Haute Grandeur Global
    • Best Boutique Hotel in North-America by Haute Grandeur Global
    • Best Island Hotel in North-America by Haute Grandeur Global
  • 2020
    • Rated #1 Hotel in Key Westby TripAdvisor
    • Rated #1 Most Romantic Hotel in the United States by TripAdvisor
    • Rated #11 Most Romantic Hotel in the World by TripAdvisor
    • Rated #5 Top Small Boutique Hotel in the USA by TripAdvisor
    • Best Luxury Boutique Hotel in North America by Haute Grandeur Global
    • Best Island Hotel in North America by Haute Grandeur Global
    • Best Romantic Hotel in North America by Haute Grandeur Global
  • 2019
  • 2018

From Our Guests

  • "Customer-service is fantastic. From champagne at check in, complimentary mimosas in the morning, complimentary happy hour in the evening to hotel staff personally walk you in to show you tour room to a candle gift at check out, the customer service is impecable. Hotel and rooms were beautiful. I wish I would have stayed in a suite your own pool, but maybe we get that next time."
    Natali G
  • "Luxury property and great location. We loved the garden and our private balcony to sip coffee and wine. Amenities were classy and the pool was amazing on the roof. The staff was friendly and accommodating for anything we needed. Highly recommend for a romantic getaway."
    Monica G.
  • "We stayed during New Years and were pleased that H20 met our expectations, especially when paying peak demand prices! Wow - so clean, fresh, relaxing, and quiet! Just a block off the southern end of Duval, it was the perfect location. And the staff was superb."
    Tammy W.